Reading time
4
min.

Seventh instalment in our series at Agence Mantu on brands facing the challenge of standardisation, this time on the power of decision. I tried an experiment the other day, just to see: I asked an AI for brand positionings. It gave me ten, then twenty when I (barely) pushed it, and all of them were plausible and fairly well phrased. Then I asked it which one to drop. The answer: a table of pros and cons. But no choice in sight.
As early as 2004, psychologist Barry Schwartz spoke of the "paradox of choice": the more options we have, the harder it becomes to decide. Twenty years later, AI has taken that logic to its conclusion, since it can generate endlessly without ever deciding. The quantity is there, but very often it does not serve the substance: what should we retain in an era marked by an acute attention crisis? For us, synthesis is the least courtesy we owe when we want to do our job as communicators properly: it's what we like to call the ecology of attention. On the brand side, the result of this crisis of choice is visible everywhere: cautious, polite messaging, designed not to offend anyone... and forgotten as soon as it's read.
Michael Porter said it already: strategy is first and foremost choosing what not to do. A singular brand is built as much on what it refuses as on what it promises. The risk is real, you will inevitably displease some people. But that is the price to pay to break out of the ambient discourse, so smooth that nothing sticks to it anymore. Patagonia made it a rule of conduct. In 2011, the brand bought a full page in the New York Times on Black Friday to say "Don't buy this jacket": don't buy this jacket if you don't need it. Eleven years later, its founder Yvon Chouinard went much further and gave up ownership of the company, valued at around 3 billion dollars. Profits that are not reinvested now fund the protection of the planet. His phrase went around the world: "Earth is now our only shareholder." Hard to make a clearer renunciation. Hard to be more singular, too.

In January 2025, while Walmart, McDonald's and Meta were scaling back their diversity programmes, Costco took the opposite path. Its board called on shareholders to reject a resolution challenging its diversity policy, and 98% of shareholders followed. Closer to home, Crédit Mutuel Alliance Fédérale has devoted 15% of its net income to a societal dividend since 2023. At the end of August, Mouvement Impact France launched a coalition to get 100 companies to do the same by 2027. Deciding also means knowing how to reverse a decision. In 2025, Klarna, which had boasted of handing its customer service over to AI, publicly acknowledged that it had put cost before quality. Its customers can once again talk to a human. Admitting you were wrong is still deciding (on this subject, I invite you to read my previous op-ed on imperfection).
Corporate communication has long been seen as the well-behaved cousin of the family: annual report, press release, carefully calibrated leadership statements. A subject for experts. That has changed: corporate decisions are now discussed at the coffee machine and weigh on purchasing choices as well as job applications. 81% of French people believe companies must change their model, and only 38% trust large companies (ADEME x GreenFlex, 2026). Brands are expected to act, and therefore to make choices that are clear and legible to society: 9 in 10 French people think they should contribute to the common good, compared with 6 in 10 in 2017 (Cision x CDA, 2025). Contributing is not something you proclaim. It means committing, and therefore making decisions that have meaning, and sometimes a cost. Most striking of all, the creative industry itself has acknowledged it. At Cannes Lions, the temple of advertising creativity, it is now corporate decisions that win the highest honours. AXA added three words to its home insurance contracts, "and domestic violence", to cover rehousing for victims. Three words in a contract, which is about as far from a glamorous subject as you can get. The result: a Titanium Grand Prix in 2025, then this year the Creative Effectiveness Grand Prix, a first in the festival's history. The 2026 Titanium also went to an insurer, Australia's Suncorp, for resilience tools and homes designed to withstand severe weather. The president of the Innovation jury, Kazuhiro Shimura (Dentsu), summed it up this way: our industry is moving from making advertising to making change. In other words, creativity now lies in decisions that, yesterday, didn't exactly get crowds going. So the profession is changing too. It is less about dressing up choices made elsewhere than about making them legible, sustaining them over time, and sometimes provoking them by asking the executive committee the awkward question: what do we refuse to do, and are we ready to say so?
At Agence Mantu, it is because we understood the performative power of brands that we decided to make "decisive communication" our signature.