Reading time
6
min.

Fourth instalment in our series on brands facing the challenge of standardisation.
Let's take a detour through etymology and open the dictionary that has been gathering a little too much dust. Rest assured: it will bring us straight back to the subject. A registered brand, or trademark, is "a manufacturer's or trade mark given by an industrialist to its products". The French word marque itself comes from a physical gesture: to mark is to leave a material trace on a thing, with a branding iron, a seal, a hand. A brand, originally, is first and foremost an imprint.
We have spent several decades dematerialising that imprint. Pixels, templates, image generators. An AI can produce a perfect product visual in ten seconds, with no product, no studio, no hand. Technology and LLMs allow us to achieve feats in creating perfect identities. Perfect, but also perfectly smooth. Because since everyone has access to these mass-production tools, everyone can reach the same result. So tech is a given, not a lever of brand differentiation.
Another grain of sand slips into the gears. An article I was reading the other day sums it up well: "the AI mock-ups of fake products flooding social media raise real questions for brands, between hype and customer disappointment with the real product." Real questions.
A brand is an imprint. And an imprint means traceability of the message's path. That is where the shoe pinches: today, who can be sure who authored a piece of communication? We have entered what we could call an unnamed "sender crisis". Proof of it can be found in a familiar environment: on LinkedIn, 1 post in 2 is reportedly written by an AI. And the platform's response is delicious: to preserve quality, it offers a new feature, "Seems like AI Slope", which lets any user flag a post that seems AI-generated. (I hope you won't flag my post, by the way, I promise it is guaranteed handmade and imperfect.) It says a lot about our times and our contradictions. But in this climate of widespread distrust, how do you get people to believe you?
That is exactly where handmade becomes a strategic weapon again.
Polaroid understood this better than anyone. Its latest campaign doesn't sell a camera, it sells "the camera for an analog life". The visuals are deliberately handwritten, captioned like Polaroids scribbled in felt-tip: "sand between your toes", "do you really remember", "if we stay in touch". Things an AI cannot generate: sand between your toes, a lived memory, a bond kept over time. And to close the loop and stay perfectly consistent right down to the media plan, the posters themselves are pasted by hand on street walls, guerrilla marketing style.
Handmade is no longer a nostalgic extra touch of soul. It has become an expectation again, and the industry itself has just consecrated it at the latest Cannes Lions. The "Apple TV Rebrand" campaign chose to literally recast the brand identity by offering a handcrafted making-of of its pared-down logo (the "+" was dropped), surprising to say the least for such a brand. The proposition is almost that of an artistic happening. Zero computer-generated imagery. The coloured light effects and glass effects of the new animated logo were shot in a studio, with real glass plates and real lighting, captured handheld rather than generated in 3D. The sound signature was composed specially by the musician Finneas. The result: an identity rematerialised with its rough edges, in place of what could (should) have been a smooth digital render for a "pure player".
The Design Grand Prix at Cannes Lions 2026 rewarded this work. The jury justified it in these terms: "gloriously human-made". It even identified an underlying trend of this edition: the rise of work visibly made by human hands in the face of the flood of generated visuals. The most prestigious prize in global advertising design has just crowned, word for word, handmade as a rebellion against AI. That's no small thing.
85% of people today trust someone who shows their doubts more, their struggles, their imperfect moments, than overly smooth messaging.* Dove has publicly taken a stand against the use of generative AI in its own campaigns, at a time when the temptation of the perfect, interchangeable face has never been so accessible. Lucca, an HR software publisher, chose to illustrate its latest campaign on AI with a hand drawing, in the style of a vintage comic strip: a droid landing on planet HR. The line is visibly human, imperfect, signed, on a subject that is precisely about the place of humans facing the machine. Back Market turned patina and wear into a selling point in its own right with "Flambant vieux", celebrating the object that has lived rather than the new object with no history. These graphic and strategic choices are a fundamental decision: to leave a trace that a machine cannot reproduce identically.
Doubt has also become structuring in the communication of business leaders: we are seeing the emergence of a new type of leadership that dares to show its vulnerabilities and thereby engages employees and stakeholders more deeply. Daring to show your flaws, contrary to the traditional vision of a uniformly all-powerful leadership facade, generates empathy among audiences. And isn't that the holy grail of all communication, since it is what allows people to project themselves and therefore set themselves in motion? Empathy is, so to speak, performative. And imperfection is its source.
Since 2 August, the AI Act has made transparency about the use of AI in communications mandatory. This European regulation implicitly reinforces the growing demand for a label guaranteeing human-made work, which we see spreading among many creatives and even beyond.
So we can predict that tomorrow, in a world saturated with generated content, everyone will be fighting over the "truly handmade". Craft, rough edges, the imperfect line already embody the new luxury, precisely because they have become rare. At Agence Mantu, handmade and the imperfection it allows is one of the six reflexes we champion to build a brand that resists standardisation.
And it seems to me that in these strange times this is excellent news: AI ultimately makes it possible to reassign value to what is imperfect, to flaws, to doubts. And I love people who doubt, as Anne Sylvestre sings so admirably. Because daring to doubt, having the ability to ask the right question, seems to me absolutely salutary at a time when everyone is rushing headlong, AI agents on autopilot, into the industrial production of answers to everything, whose usefulness or purpose can sometimes no longer be traced.
What was the question again?
* Source: J'ai Un Pote Dans La Com x Heaven 2026